Amethyst Fakes vs. Real: 10 Ways To Spot Them

Amethyst Fakes vs. Real: 10 Ways To Spot Them

Definition Of Amethyst

What is amethyst? It's a gemstone with an alluring beauty, captivating history and mysterious properties.Its name originates from the Greek 'amethustos', which translates to 'not intoxicated'. This was because ancient Greeks believed that wearing amethyst could provide protection against intoxication.

The most valuable type of amethyst is usually darkly colored but also transparent, meaning no cloudiness or fractures are present within the stone. As well as being highly sought after in jewelry, these stones have become popular among collectors who value their historical significance and rarity.

When searching for real amethysts, there are certain things that should be taken into consideration such as clarity, shape and size, carat weight (weight measurement) and cut quality – all contributing factors when determining authenticity.

By understanding more about these key aspects, buyers will be able to identify whether they are dealing with genuine amethysts or counterfeits on the market today.

Characteristics Of Real Amethysts

Now that you know what an amethyst is, it's important to learn how to spot a genuine one. Natural amethysts have certain characteristics that can help you differentiate them from fake stones.

Here are 10 ways to distinguish real amethysts from fakes:

  • Color: Genuine amethysts usually display different shades of purple, ranging from light lavender to deep violet-blue. Fake versions tend to be too bright and more saturated in color than the authentic ones.
  • Clarity: Authentic amethysts will often contain some visible inclusions or imperfections within the stone. Fakes may appear too clear with no visible blemishes or flaws at all.
  • Cut: Amethyst features such as facets should be well-defined on true specimens, while they may appear slightly duller on fakes due to improper polishing techniques.
  • Weight: Real stones typically weigh more than their synthetic counterparts as natural minerals contain denser molecules which make up its mass.
  • Transparency & Refraction: True amethysts will allow light to pass through them fairly easily while also refracting it back out brightly, whereas fake stones won't show this effect so clearly.
  • Hardness: The Mohs scale of mineral hardness rates authentic gems higher (7 - 7 ½ ) compared to lab-created varieties ( 6 ¼ - 6 ½ ). So when testing for scratch resistance using a sharp object like a knife blade, if your gemstone sustains very few marks then it's likely genuine!
  • Thermal Conductivity Test: A thermal conductivity test involves heating up a metal pin and touching it against the surface of the stone for several seconds . If heat doesn’t transfer quickly into the gemstone , then chances are it’s not an authentic piece.
  • Specific Gravity Test: This requires putting your suspected gemstone into water and weighing it before and after immersion . If there is much discrepancy between these two measurements , then again , chances are you have something other than a true amethyst .
  • Ultraviolet Light Reaction: When exposed to UV radiation , many organic substances emit fluorescence but most crystals don’t react this way . However , real amethysts do produce strong fluorescent reactions under ultraviolet lights confirming their authenticity .

10 ) Cost : You get what you pay for ; if an offer seems too good to be true – beware ! True quality cannot come cheaply and thus any suspiciously cheap offers should alert your suspicion about possible imitations . In summary, by looking out for these key characteristics you can identify genuine amethysts and avoid buying knockoffs instead!

Testing Color And Clarity

Here are some tips for determining authenticity using these methods. First off, it's important to understand that when evaluating any gemstone, there's much more to consider than just its color.

Color grading examines how intense or vibrant the hue is on a scale from lightest to darkest; while clarity grading looks at the presence of internal features such as growth lines, fractures and blemishes. The higher up on each respective scale your amethyst falls, the better quality and thusly more valuable it will be deemed.

When comparing fakes with genuine stones, pay attention to their appearance under natural daylight versus artificial lighting sources. A real stone should have more vibrancy in sunlight and greater sparkle indoors since it has been cut within industry-standard angles for maximum brilliance. Additionally, examine the facets closely: authentic ones should appear smooth with no jagged edges or uneven surfaces - signs of a poorly made reproduction piece.

Amethysts come in various grades of color intensity and clarity, so authenticating one requires careful examination and comparison against known standards. With patience and practice you’ll soon be able to spot even the most convincing counterfeit!

Examining The Cut And Shape

Once you've tested and confirmed the color and clarity of an amethyst stone, it's time to move on to examining its cut and shape. The cut refers to how well the gemstone has been fashioned from a lump of rough material into something that reflects light in certain ways—while the shape is simply what the finished product looks like.

To tell if a piece of amethyst is real or fake, there are several specific characteristics you can look for in both the cut and shape. The first thing to examine when looking at an amethyst’s cut is whether it has facets which were polished properly.

Facets should be symmetrical with smooth edges, so if they appear uneven or jagged then this could indicate a fake stone. Also check for flatness; ideal cuts will be evenly rounded without any bumps or hollows. Any irregularities here may suggest a low-quality imitation instead of genuine amethyst. Shape-wise, look out for stones that have unnatural curves or lines along their surface; these often reveal synthetic materials rather than authentic ones.

Additionally, compare different pieces side by side – real amethysts tend to have uniformity in size and shape, whereas fakes can vary wildly from one another even within a single batch due to imperfect manufacturing processes. Trust your judgement as you assess each individual piece – if anything seems off about its appearance then double check before buying it!

Knowing all these key points will help ensure that whatever type of amethyst you purchase is truly genuine and not just an imitation made to deceive buyers. It takes practice but eventually it becomes easier to spot the subtle differences between real stones versus fake ones – taking extra care during inspection will help protect against being duped by unscrupulous sellers!

Looking For Inclusions

When it comes to differentiating between real and fake amethyst, inclusions are a great place to start. Inclusions refer to the internal patterns and imperfections found within a gemstone - these are also referred to as blemishes or fractures. The presence of inclusions may be indicative of authenticity, since most fakes don't have them.

Here's how you can spot an inclusion:

  • Take a close look at the stone through magnification.
  • Pay attention to any unusual patterns that appear inside the amethyst itself.
  • Look for bubbles or swirls on the surface of the gemstone that weren't present before.
  • Inspect both sides of each crystal carefully with your eyes or magnifying glass.
  • Check if there is any visible evidence of crystalline structure such as striations or cleavages running throughout the stone’s interior.

If you're still having trouble spotting inclusions, try using a loupe - this is a small magnifying tool used by jewellers and collectors when examining gems and minerals up close. It will help make spotting inclusions much easier! If you find some irregularities while inspecting an amethyst with a loupe, chances are they were created naturally, making it more likely that your amethyst is genuine rather than artificial.

So next time you come across an amethyst, take out your loupe and check for inclusions! You might just discover something special about your little piece of natural beauty!

Assessing Carat Weight

Now that we've discussed looking for inclusions, let's turn to assessing carat weight. One of the most reliable ways to determine if an amethyst is real or fake is by weighing it. Genuine amethysts usually have a higher density than imitation stones and so are heavier for their size.

A quick way to assess the stone’s weight is with a gem scale, which uses milligram measurements to gauge its true weight. If you don't own one yourself, your local jeweler should be able to help with this. Another easy way to check whether the amethyst’s carat weight matches what it says on the label is by comparing its size against other known weights of genuine stones.

For example, a 2-carat round brilliant cut genuine amethyst should measure around 8mm across - any larger or smaller could indicate it may be artificial.

Knowing these things can help ensure that you’re getting exactly what you expect out of your amethyst purchase - real or not!

Investigating Reflection And Refraction

One of the best ways is to look at reflection and refraction. Reflection angles, refractive index, refraction rate, reflection color, and refraction patterns are all key indicators for determining authenticity in an amethyst stone. When investigating reflection angles, a higher angle means more accuracy when judging if the amethyst is genuine or not.

The same goes for refractive index; when testing with a polariscope, you should see two images which overlap each other perfectly within specific viewing angles— this indicates authenticity. Additionally, examining the refraction rate will help determine if it’s real or fake — as a general rule, genuine stones have a lower rate than artificial ones do.

Finally, observing both the reflection color and various refraction patterns are reliable methods too. Generally speaking, authentic amethysts tend to show bright flashes of vibrant purple whereas fakes usually appear less vivid in terms of hue and clarity.

Furthermore, they often have different shapes inside them due to their varied chemical compositions compared to natural stones - these differences in shape create unique sets of intricate patterns when viewed under magnification.

It takes knowledge and experience to successfully spot counterfeit gems but understanding how reflections and refractions work can significantly increase your chances!

Checking Specific Gravity

As we move away from assessing hardness and durability, let's look at another way to check for amethyst fakes. Checking specific gravity can be a great tool to identify fake amethyst. Specific gravity is the ratio of an object's density compared to that of water.

As real amethyst has different densities than other materials used in crafting counterfeit gems, its specific gravity can help differentiate between genuine and imitation stones. To begin checking amethyst’s specific gravity, you'll need some special tools such as a pocket scale, gem refractometer or hydrostatic weighing balance.

This will allow you to measure the stone accurately by comparing it with the weight of equal volumes of water.These techniques involve expensive equipment and specialized skills however, so unless you're working on large batches of unknown material they may not be worth investigating further.

But rest assured knowing that testing specific gravity is often enough to authenticate most pieces - identifying fakes before making any investments!

Examining Fluorescence And Phosphorescence

When examining amethyst fakes, it is essential to look at the gemstone’s fluorescence and phosphorescence. These characteristics are a great indicator of authenticity.

  • Fluorescence Examination: Genuine amethysts will generally exhibit strong red-orange or yellowish-orange reactions when exposed to ultraviolet light. Fake stones may appear blue or green in comparison. The intensity of this reaction should also be taken into consideration; if the color appears weak or faded, chances are it is not genuine.
  • Phosphorescence Examination:After being exposed to UV rays, an authentic amethyst should remain illuminated for several seconds after the source has been removed from view. Fakes typically do not show much activity here as they lack the crystalline structure that allows phosphorescent properties to be exhibited.

It is important to note that some genuine amethysts may display minimal responses with both tests due to their composition. However, by familiarizing yourself with fluorescence and phosphorescence characteristics associated with authentic amethysts, you'll have a better chance at spotting any suspicious gems on sight!

Analyzing Thermal Conductivity

Analyzing thermal conductivity is like a detective searching for clues. It can help tell the difference between real and fake amethysts by looking at how heat passes through them. Thermal conductivity measures how well an object transfers heat, with higher numbers representing better heat transfer rates.

By analyzing their thermal conductivity, we can determine which stones are genuine amethysts and which ones are not. When testing for thermal conductivity, it is important to compare the unknown stone to one that has been verified as authentic. This allows us to accurately measure the differences in their respective heat transfer rate.

The first step of this process involves measuring both objects’ temperatures using a thermometer or digital infrared camera (DIRC). Then, place both items on a hotplate set at the same temperature and observe how quickly they each reach equilibrium. If the fakes take longer than expected to adjust to the new temperature, then you know they have inferior thermal properties compared to their natural counterparts.

The final way to test for authenticity via thermal conductivity is by comparing the two types of materials side-by-side while being heated up simultaneously. Place both samples onto a metal plate connected to an electrical current and observe how quickly they both reach maximum temperature.

Real amethysts will usually absorb more energy than phony imitations due to their superior thermal properties; thus making them easier to identify when tested under similar conditions. With these methods combined, you should be able to easily detect any fake amethyst stones before buying them!

Chemical Tests To Identify Fakes

When trying to spot amethyst fakes, one of the most reliable methods is to conduct chemical tests. This involves testing the stone's elemental composition and hardness using scientific instruments such as spectrometers and diamond testers.

With these tools, you can differentiate between a real amethyst gemstone and an imitation or synthetic version. The first step in conducting chemical tests for identifying amethyst fakes is to obtain a sample from your stone. Depending on its size, this could be done with a microdrill or laser drill.

The next step is to analyze it under magnification – usually magnified up to 400x - which will help determine if impurities are present that would indicate the stone is not genuine. It’s at this point that you can use either optical spectroscopy or X-ray fluorescence analysis for further examinations of the crystal structure and elemental composition of the material in question.

Finally, if neither method provides conclusive evidence, then hardness tests should be carried out on both samples taken from your original piece and any suspected fake counterparts.

This test results can often reveal whether a product has been treated or if it is artificially produced by comparing its hardness level against international standards applicable to natural stones like amethysts.

Magnetic Responsiveness Tests

Now that we've discussed chemical tests to identify fakes, let's move on to magnetic responsiveness tests. This is one of the most effective ways of telling real amethyst from a fake. The test involves using a magnet and observing how it reacts with the stone in question.

Real amethysts are not responsive to magnets so if your magnet has no effect on the stone you're testing, then it's likely genuine. However, some synthetic stones contain iron-oxide which makes them magnetically active so be sure to check for this before drawing any conclusions about authenticity.

You can also use other kinds of metal detectors such as an electrical conductivity meter or XRF analyzer for more accurate readings. Overall, magnetic response tests are great tools for determining whether or not an amethyst is real or a fake.

They provide reliable results without having to resort to destructive methods like cutting open the stone or applying harsh chemicals. So if you need to authenticate your precious amethyst gemstones quickly and accurately, these tests will do the job!

X-Ray Diffraction

It's estimated that up to 30% of all amethysts are fakes. So, if you're looking for a genuine gemstone, it pays to learn how to spot imitations. One way is using X-ray diffraction and here we'll explain what this process entails and how it can help identify fake amethysts.

X-Ray Diffraction (XRD) involves emitting electromagnetic radiation at the sample being tested and measuring the scattered waves generated by its atomic structure. This method provides useful information on the mineral composition of a specimen, including any added components or treatments it has undergone.

The results are then analysed against data from known samples of real amethyst stones which have already been studied in labs with an XRD device. By comparing these two sets of readings, one can determine whether the sample under scrutiny is natural or not.

In some cases, even if the stone appears convincing at first glance, closer inspection with XRD will reveal subtle differences between authentic gems and their manmade counterparts - thus helping distinguish those that may look like genuine but are actually fakes!

These discrepancies might be too small for our eyes to detect without specialised equipment; however they become apparent when studied through X-Ray Diffraction – making this tool invaluable for identifying counterfeit gems such as fake amethysts.


As someone who loves the beauty and mystique of amethyst, it's important to know how to spot a fake. A good eye is essential for distinguishing between real and imitation stones. By looking carefully at color, clarity, cut and shape, thermal conductivity, chemical makeup and magnetic responsiveness—not to mention X-ray diffraction—you can be sure you're getting what you pay for.

At first glance, real amethysts may seem too good to be true with their striking purple hue and shimmering facets. But don't let yourself be fooled by cleverly crafted counterfeits that try to masquerade as the genuine article! 

With your newfound knowledge about spotting fakes in tow, you can now confidently purchase authentic pieces that will last through many generations like a timeless treasure trove.It's an investment worth making: one 'fake' slip could cost you dearly in both money and reputation; however investing in the real deal adds sparkle to any collection - just like a diamond in the rough.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.